The Best Peanut Butters of 2025
Peanut butter is more than just a sandwich staple—it’s a versatile kitchen hero for smoothies, baking, and straight-from-the-jar snacking. With countless brands vying for shelf space, we scoured recent taste tests and expert reviews from 2025 to curate this list of the top five. Our selections prioritize flavor, texture, ingredient quality, and overall crowd-pleasing appeal, drawing from blind tastings, nutrition scores, and chef endorsements. Whether you crave creamy smoothness or natural simplicity, there’s a jar here for you.
1. Teddie All Natural Smooth Peanut Butter
4.6 out of 5 Ratings
Teddie takes the crown for its unbeatable balance of nutty depth and spreadable texture. Made with just roasted peanuts and a touch of salt, it delivers a fresh-roasted peanut punch that’s grainy yet luxurious—perfect for PB&J or swirling into oatmeal. Tasters rave about its “next-level” toastiness and ideal saltiness, making it a pantry essential without any added sugars or oils. It’s the unanimous favorite in multiple panels for its versatility in both sweet and savory dishes.
2. Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread
4.6 out of 5 Ratings
A nostalgic classic with a healthier twist, Skippy Natural earns its spot thanks to its ultra-smooth consistency and well-rounded flavor that avoids separation. Experts love how it bakes beautifully in cookies or blends into satay sauces, offering robust peanut taste with just enough subtle sweetness from palm oil (no hydrogenated oils here). It’s the top pick among food pros for its familiarity and reliability, shining in everything from energy bites to chunky varieties for texture lovers.
3. Jif Creamy Peanut Butter
4.7 out of 5 Ratings
Jif is the gold standard for creamy, no-stir indulgence—think supermarket perfection in every scoop. Its emulsified formula ensures effortless spreading, with a pronounced peanuttiness tempered by a hint of molasses for that signature sweet-salty harmony. Ideal for baking peanut butter cookies or topping toast, it stands out for its lingering nutty flavor and synergy with jam, earning high marks in taste tests for being less cloying than competitors.
4. Justin’s Honey Peanut Butter
4.5 out of 5 Ratings
Justin’s Honey Peanut Butter 16oz. Jar, Gluten Free, Non-GMO, Responsibly Sourced
For purists seeking simplicity, Justin’s Honey Peanut Butter wins with its single-ingredient purity: just organic dry-roasted peanuts (skins included for extra nutrition). It boasts an excellent 94/100 health score, delivering a decadent, unsweetened nuttiness that’s versatile for smoothies or as a dip. Reviewers highlight its organic quality and lack of additives, making it a budget-friendly powerhouse that punches above its price in flavor complexity.
5. Santa Cruz Organic Creamy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter
4.6 out of 5 Ratings
Rounding out the list is Santa Cruz, celebrated for its bold, dark-roasted profile and minimal ingredients—organic peanuts with a whisper of salt. It offers a sweet-yet-nutty taste with lower sodium, providing a powerful peanut hit that’s spreadable and PB&J-ready. High scorers appreciate its clean label and fresh vibe, positioning it as a top organic choice for health-conscious fans who don’t skimp on taste.
When choosing your next jar, consider your needs: natural options like Teddie or Trader Joe’s for minimalism, or stabilized classics like Skippy and Jif for convenience. All these picks are widely available and score high on freshness—grab one and elevate your next snack!
